Kodi pali umboni wosonyeza kuti Yesu anaukitsidwa?

1) Kuikidwa kwa Yesu: zalembedwa m'mabuku ambiri odziyimira pawokha (Mauthenga Abwino anayi, kuphatikiza zomwe zidagwiritsidwa ntchito ndi Maliko zomwe malinga ndi Rudolf Pesch zidachitika zaka zisanu ndi ziwiri Yesu atapachikidwa pamtanda ndipo zimachokera ku nkhani zowona ndi maso, makalata angapo kuchokera kwa Paul, omwe adalembedwa kale za Mauthenga Abwino ndipo ngakhale pafupi ndi zowona, ndi Gospel owonjezera wa Peter) ndipo ichi ndichinthu chotsimikizika pamaziko a umboni wotsimikizira kambiri. Kuphatikiza apo, kuyikidwa m'manda kwa Yesu kudzera mwa Joseph wa Arimathea, membala wa Sanhedrin Yachiyuda, ndikodalirika chifukwa kumakwaniritsa zomwe zimadziwika kuti ndi zamanyazi: monga wophunzira Raymond Edward Brown adafotokozera (mu "Imfa ya Mesiya", 2 ma v. ., Garden City 1994, p.1240-1). Kuika maliro a Yesu kwa Joseph waku Arimathea "ndizotheka" chifukwa sizowerengeka momwe mamembala ampingo woyambilira angayamikire kwambiri kukhala membala wa Sanhedrini Yachiyuda, pomvetsetsa mdani wawo (iwowa anali amisiri omanga nyumba za Yesu). Pazifukwa izi ndi zina zomwe John At Robinson wa University of Cambridge, wakuika maliro, "kuyikidwa m'manda kwa Yesu ndi" umboni umodzi wakale kwambiri komanso wotsimikizika wonena za Yesu "(" The Human Face of God ", Westminster 1973, p. 131 )

2) Manda atapezeka wopanda kanthu: Lamlungu atapachikidwa, manda a Yesu adapezeka wopanda gulu la azimayi. Izi zimakwaniritsa chitsimikizo cha umboni wambiri womwe umatsimikiziridwa ndi magawo osiyanasiyana odziyimira pawokha (Gospel of Mateyo, Marko ndi Yohane, ndi Machitidwe a Atumwi 2,29 ndi 13,29). Kuphatikiza apo, kuti omwe akutsutsa manda opanda kanthu ndi azimayi, omwe amawaganizira kuti alibe ulamulilo (ngakhale m'mabwalo achiyuda) amatsimikizira kuti nkhaniyi ndiyowona, ndikukwaniritsa chitsimikizo chochititsa manyazi. Chifukwa chake katswiri wina waku Austria, Jacob Kremer, adati: "pomwe ambiri mwa akatswiriwo adawona kuti zonena za manda ndizopanda chodalirika" ("Die Osterevangelien - Geschichten um Geschichte", Katholisches Bibelwerk, 1977, pp. 49-50).

3) Maonekedwe a Yesu pambuyo pa imfa: m'malo osiyanasiyana komanso m'malo osiyanasiyana anthu osiyanasiyana anena kuti adakumana ndi zowonera za Yesu pambuyo pa imfa yake. Nthawi zambiri Paulo amatchula zochitika izi m'makalata ake, poganiza kuti zidalembedwa pafupi ndi zochitikazo ndikuganizira za chidziwitso chake ndi anthu omwe akukhudzidwa, izi sizingafanane ndi nthano chabe. Kuphatikiza apo, iwo amapezeka m'malo osiyanasiyana pawokha, kukhutiritsa kutsimikizira kokwanira (umboni wa Petro ukutsimikiziridwa ndi Luka ndi Paul; kuyang'ana kwa khumi ndi awiriwo kwatsimikiziridwa ndi Luka, Yohane ndi Paul; kochokera kwa azimayi akutsimikiziridwa ndi Matthew ndi John, ndi ena otero. Wofufuza wokayikira wa ku Germany wa New Testament Gerd Lüdemann adatsimikiza kuti: "Zitha kutengedwa ngati mbiri yakale kuti Peter ndi ophunzira adakumana ndi zomwe Yesu atamwalira momwe adawonekera kwa iwo monga Khristu woukitsidwayo »(" Kodi Yesu Amachita Chiyani Kwenikweni? ", Westminster John Knox Press 1995, p.8).

4) Kusintha kwakukuru m'malingaliro a ophunzira: atatha kuthawa mwamantha panthawi yopachikidwa Yesu, ophunzira adadzidzimuka mwachangu komanso mochokera pansi pamtima kuti adauka kwa akufa, ngakhale anali Ayuda. Zambiri mwakuti mwadzidzidzi anali ololera ngakhale kufa chifukwa cha chowonadi cha chikhulupiriro ichi. Katswiri wotchuka wa ku Britain, NT Wright, adati: "Ichi ndichifukwa chake, monga wolemba mbiri, sindingathe kufotokoza za chikhazikitso cha Chikristu choyambirira pokhapokha Yesu atauka kwa akufa, ndikusiya manda opanda kanthu kumbuyo kwake." ("Yesu Wopanda Wophunzitsidwa", Christian Today, 13/09/1993).