Kodi Papa Benedict ati chiyani za makondomu?

Mu 2010, L'Osservatore Romano, nyuzipepala ya Vatican City, adasindikiza zolemba kuchokera ku Light of the World, kuyankhulana kwapabuku kwa Papa Benedict XVI kochitidwa ndi yemwe anali wolankhulana naye kwa nthawi yayitali, mtolankhani waku Germany a Peter Seewald.

Padziko lonse lapansi, mitu yankhani ikusonyeza kuti Papa Benedict wasintha tchalitchi cha Katolika kwa nthawi yayitali chokana njira zakulera. Mitu yaying'ono ikunena kuti Papa adalengeza kuti kugwiritsa ntchito kondomu "kunali koyenera mwamakhalidwe" kapena "kololedwa" kuyesa kuletsa kufala kwa HIV, kachilombo kamene kamadziwika kuti ndi komwe kumayambitsa matenda a Edzi.

Mbali inayi, British Catholic Herald idasindikiza nkhani yabwino yofananira ndi zomwe Papa ananena ndi zomwe adachita kwa iwo ("Makondomu atha kukhala" gawo loyamba "pakukhazikitsa chiwerewere, atero Papa"), pomwe a Damian Thompson, Polemba pa bulogu yake ku Telegraph, adati "Akatolika omwe amatsata mosamala amatsutsa atolankhani chifukwa chankhani ya kondomu" koma adafunsa "kodi adawoloka mwachinsinsi ndi Papa?"

Ngakhale ndikuganiza kuti kusanthula kwa Thompson ndikulondola kuposa kulakwitsa, ndikuganiza kuti Thompson mwiniwake amapita patali kwambiri akamalemba kuti: "Sindikumvetsetsa momwe olemba Katolika anganene kuti Papa sananene kuti makondomu akhoza kukhala oyenera kapena ovomerezeka, munthawi yomwe kulephera kwawo kugwiritsa ntchito kufalitsa kachilomboka “. Vutoli, mbali zonse ziwiri, limayamba chifukwa chotenga mlandu winawake womwe sugwirizana kwenikweni ndi zomwe Mpingo umaphunzitsa zakulera kopitilira muyeso ndikutsata mfundo za chikhalidwe.

Ndiye kodi Papa Benedict ananena chiyani, ndipo kodi zikuyimiradi kusintha kwa chiphunzitso cha Katolika? Poyamba kuyankha funsoli, tiyenera kuyamba ndi zomwe Atate Woyera sananene.

Zomwe Papa Benedict sananene
Poyamba, Papa Benedict sanasinthe lingaliro limodzi laziphunzitso zachikatolika pa zachiwerewere. Zowonadi, kwinakwake pokambirana ndi Peter Seewald, Papa Benedict alengeza kuti Humanae vitae, cholembedwa cha Papa Paul VI chaku 1968 chokhudza njira zakulera ndikuchotsa mimbayo, "zinali zolondola mwaulosi". Anatsimikiziranso mfundo yayikulu ya Humanae Vitae - kuti kupatukana kwa zinthu zosagwirizana komanso zobereka zokhudzana ndi kugonana (m'mawu a Papa Paul VI) "zikutsutsana ndi chifuniro cha Woyambitsa Moyo".

Kuphatikiza apo, Papa Benedict sananene kuti kugwiritsa ntchito kondomu ndi "koyenera" kapena "ndikololedwa" kuletsa kufala kwa kachirombo ka HIV. Zowonadi, adachita zonse zomwe angathe kuti atsimikizire zomwe ananena, kumayambiriro kwa ulendo wake wopita ku Africa ku 2009, "kuti sitingathe kuthana ndi vutoli pogawa kondomu." Vutoli ndi lakuya kwambiri ndipo limakhudza kumvetsetsa kosagwirizana ndi chiwerewere komwe kumayika zoyeserera zogonana pamwambamwamba kuposa zamakhalidwe. Papa Benedict akufotokoza izi momveka bwino akamakambirana za "zomwe zimatchedwa chiphunzitso cha ABC":

Kudziletsa - Khalani wokhulupirika - Kondomu, komwe kondomu imangokhala njira yomaliza, pomwe mfundo ziwirizi sizigwira ntchito. Izi zikutanthauza kuti kusanja kosavuta pa kondomu kumatanthawuza kupeputsa zakugonana, zomwe, pambuyo pake, ndiye gwero lowopsa la malingaliro osawonanso kugonana monga chisonyezero cha chikondi, koma mtundu wa mankhwala omwe anthu amapereka iwowo.
Nanga ndichifukwa chiyani olemba ndemanga ambiri akuti Papa Benedict adaganiza kuti "makondomu akhoza kukhala oyenera kapena ololedwa, polephera kufalitsa kachilombo ka HIV"? Chifukwa sanamvetse bwino chitsanzo choperekedwa ndi Papa Benedict.

Zomwe Papa Benedict anena
Pofotokoza mfundo yake pa "kupeputsa kugonana", Papa Benedict adati:

Pakhoza kukhala maziko pamilandu ya anthu ena, monga ngati hule wamwamuna amagwiritsa ntchito kondomu, pomwe izi zingakhale gawo loyamba panjira yolowera kukhazikitsidwa, lingaliro loyamba la udindo [kutsindika] sikuti zonse ndizololedwa ndipo simungathe kuchita zomwe mukufuna.
Mosakhalitsa adatsimikiza ndikutsimikiziranso zomwe adawona m'mbuyomu:

Koma imeneyo si njira yothanirana ndi zoipa za kachirombo ka HIV. Izi zitha kupezeka pakupanga zogonana.
Olemba ndemanga ochepa kwambiri akuwoneka kuti akumvetsetsa mfundo ziwiri zofunika:

Ziphunzitso za Tchalitchi zakusavomerezeka kwa njira zakulera zimalunjika kwa okwatirana.
"Makhalidwe abwino," monga Papa Benedict akugwiritsira ntchito, akunena za zotsatira zomwe zingakhalepo za chinthu china, chomwe sichinena kanthu za khalidwe la zomwezo.
Mfundo ziwirizi zimayendera limodzi. Wachiwerewere (wamwamuna kapena wamkazi) akachita chigololo, zochita zake zimakhala zosayenera. Sadzipeputsa ngati sagwiritsa ntchito njira zakulera panthawi yochita chigololo; kapenanso kupangidwa kukhala kosayenera ngati agwiritsa ntchito. Ziphunzitso za Tchalitchi zakusavomerezeka kwa njira zakulera zimachitika kwathunthu pakugwiritsa ntchito njira zogonana, ndiye kuti, pankhani yogona.

Pamenepa, Quentin de la Bedoyere anali ndi positi yabwino kwambiri patsamba la Catholic Herald patangopita masiku ochepa mpungwepungwewo utayamba. Monga ananenera:

Palibe lingaliro la kulera lomwe linapangidwa kunja kwaukwati, kugonana amuna kapena akazi okhaokha kapena amuna kapena akazi okhaokha, komanso panalibe chifukwa chilichonse chogwiritsira ntchito Magisterium.
Izi ndi zomwe pafupifupi olemba onse, kapena otsutsa, ataya. Pamene Papa Benedict akunena kuti kugwiritsa ntchito kondomu ndi hule pochita uhule, poyesa kupewa kufalitsa kachirombo ka HIV, "ikhoza kukhala gawo loyamba pakukhazikitsa chikhalidwe, lingaliro loyamba la udindo, ”akungonena kuti, pamunthu payekha, hule limatha kuzindikira kuti pali zambiri pamoyo kuposa kugonana.

Wina akhoza kusiyanitsa mlanduwu ndi nkhani yofala kwambiri yoti wafilosofi wamasiku ano a Michel Foucault, atamva kuti akumwalira ndi Edzi, adayendera malo osambiramo amuna kapena akazi okhaokha ndi cholinga chofuna kupatsira ena HIV. (Zowonadi, sizowoneka kuganiza kuti Papa Benedict anali ndi malingaliro a Foucault polankhula ndi Seewald.)

Zachidziwikire, kuyesa kuteteza kufala kwa kachilombo ka HIV pogwiritsa ntchito kondomu, chida cholephera kugwirabe ntchito, uku akuchita chiwerewere (mwachitsanzo, chiwerewere chilichonse kunja kwa banja) sichina koma " sitepe yoyamba. " Koma zikuyenera kudziwikiratu kuti chitsanzo chomwe Papa wapereka sichikhudzanso kugwiritsa ntchito njira zakulera zabanja.

Inde, monga a Quentin de la Bedoyere ananenera, Papa Benedict akanatha kupereka chitsanzo cha banja lomwe wina ali ndi kachilombo ka HIV ndipo winayo alibe, koma iye sanatero. M'malo mwake, adasankha kukambirana zomwe sizikunenedwa ndi Tchalitchi pankhani yolerera.

Chitsanzo china
Tangoganizirani ngati Papa akadakambirana za banja lomwe silinakwatirane lomwe limachita chiwerewere pogwiritsa ntchito njira yolerera. Ngati banjali pang'onopang'ono lazindikira kuti njira zakulera zimayika zikhumbo zakugonana pamwambamwamba kuposa zamakhalidwe abwino, kenako ndikuganiza zosiya kugwiritsa ntchito njira zakulera kwinaku akupitilizabe kugonana kunja kwa banja, Papa Benedict akananena moyenera kuti "iyi ikhoza kukhala gawo loyamba pakhalidwe, lingaliro loyamba laudindo, panjira yodziwitsa anthu kuti sizololedwa zonse ndipo munthu sangachite zomwe akufuna".

Komabe, ngati Papa Benedict angagwiritse ntchito fanizoli, kodi wina angaganize kuti izi zikutanthauza kuti Papa amakhulupirira kuti kugonana musanalowe m'banja "ndizoyenera" kapena "kololedwa" bola makondomu asagwiritsidwe ntchito?

Kusamvetsetsa zomwe Papa Benedict anali kuyesera kunena kunawonetsa izi pamfundo ina: Amuna amakono, kuphatikiza Akatolika ambiri, ali ndi "kondomu yoyera bwino", zomwe "zimatanthawuza kupeputsa kugonana".

Ndipo yankho lokhazikika ndikuti kupeputsa kumapezeka, monga nthawi zonse, mu chiphunzitso chosasintha cha Mpingo wa Katolika pazolinga ndi malekezero azakugonana.