Imibuzo iphakama malunga nesibhengezo sikaPopu Francis kwimibutho yabasebenzi besini esifanayo

UBr. Antonio Spadaro, SJ, umlawuli wephephancwadi lamaJesuit iLa Civiltà Cattolica, utshilo uLwesithathu ngokuhlwa ukuba intetho kaPopu Francis yokuxhasa imibutho yabasebenzi besini esinye "ayonto intsha" kwaye oko akuthethi kutshintsho imfundiso yamaKatolika. Kodwa ukujonga komfundisi kwaveza amathandabuzo malunga nemvelaphi yezimvo zikaPopu Francis kwimibutho yabasebenzi, eboniswe kwi-documentary esandula ukukhutshwa ethi "Francesco".

Kwividiyo ekhutshwe yi-Tv2000, abachasi beendaba kwiNgqungquthela yoBhishophu base-Italiya, u-Spadaro uthe "umlawuli wefilimu u" Francesco "wenza uluhlu lodliwanondlebe olwenziwe noPapa Francis ngokuhamba kwexesha, enika isishwankathelo esikhulu sobupapa bakhe kunye nexabiso ukuhamba kwakhe “.

"Phakathi kwezinye izinto, kukho imiqolo eyahlukeneyo ethathwe kudliwanondlebe noValentina Alazraki, intatheli yaseMexico, kwaye kudliwanondlebe uPopu Francis uthetha ngelungelo lokhuseleko olusemthethweni kwizini ezitshatileyo kodwa ngaphandle kwayo nayiphi na indlela echaphazela imfundiso. ”Utshilo uSpadaro.

I-Tv2000 ayihambelani neVatican kwaye uSpadaro akasosithethi seVatican.

NgoLwesithathu, umlawuli wexwebhu, u-Evgeny Afineevsky, uxelele i-CNA kunye nezinye iintatheli ukuba ingxelo kapopu exhasa ukwamkelwa ngokusemthethweni kwemibutho yabasebenzi besini esinye yenziwa ngexesha lodliwanondlebe nomlawuli ngokwakhe waqhuba noPapa. Francis.

Kodwa udliwanondlebe uPope Francis alunike u-Alazraki we-Televisa wafotwa kwindawo enye, kunye nokukhanya okufanayo nokubonakala njengamazwi kapopu kwimibutho yabasebenzi eyayisasazwe "kuFrancis", ecebisa ukuba uqatshelo luza Udliwanondlebe noAlazraki, hayi udliwanondlebe no-Afineevsky.

U-Spadaro uthe ngo-Okthobha u-21 "akukho nto intsha" kwintetho kapopu kwimibutho yabasebenzi.

"Olu dliwanondlebe lukhutshwe kwakudala esele lufunyenwe kumaphephandaba," wongeze watsho uSpadaro.

NgoLwesithathu, umfundisi uxelele I-Associated Press ukuba "akukho nto intsha kuba iyinxalenye yodliwanondlebe," esongeza ukuba "kubonakala kungaqhelekanga ukuba awukhumbuli."

Ngelixa udliwanondlebe lweAlazraki lwakhutshwa yiTelevisa ngoJuni 1, 2019, izimvo zikapopu kumthetho wemanyano yabasebenzi zazingafakwanga kuhlobo olupapashiweyo, kwaye zazingazange zibonwe ngaphambili luluntu nangayiphi na imeko.

Ngapha koko, uAlazraki uxelele i-CNA ukuba akakhumbuli upopu esenza amagqabantshintshi kwimibutho yabasebenzi, nangona okuthelekiswayo kubonisa ukuba lo mbono ngokuqinisekileyo uvela kudliwanondlebe.

Akukacaci ukuba imifanekiso engalungiswanga yodliwanondlebe ka-Alazraki, uSpadaro ebebonakala eyazi kwintetho yakhe ngoLwesithathu, yafumaneka ku-Afineevsky ngexesha lokuveliswa kwe-documentary yakhe.

Ngomhla we-28 kaMeyi, i-2019, iVictoria News, iindaba ezisemthethweni zaseVatican, zapapasha umbono-ndlebe ka-Alazraki, owawungenanto yakwenza nopopu kwimibutho yabasebenzi.

Kudliwanondlebe kunye noCorriere della Sera ka-2014, uPopu Francis wathetha ngokufutshane malunga nemibutho yabasebenzi emva kokuba eceliwe ukuba athethe ngayo. Upopu wahlula phakathi komtshato, ophakathi kwendoda nomfazi, kunye nezinye iintlobo zobudlelwane ezivunyiweyo ngurhulumente. UPopu uFrancis akazange angenelele ngexesha lodliwanondlebe malunga nengxoxo e-Itali malunga nemibutho yabasebenzi besini esinye, kwaye isithethi kamva sakwenza kwacaca ukuba wayengenanjongo yokwenza njalo.

UPope Francis ukwathetha ngemibutho yabasebenzi kwincwadi engaziwayo ka-2017 “uPape François. Politique et société ”, ngugqirha wezentlalo wase-France u-Dominique Wolton, obhale lo mbhalo emva kodliwanondlebe no-Pope Francis.

Kwinguqulelo yesiNgesi yale ncwadi, osihloko sithi "A future of Faith: The Path of Change in Politics and Society", uWolton uxelela uPope Francis ukuba "amafanasini awafanelanga" umtshato ". Abanye bathanda umanyano loluntu (sic) Yonke inzima. Ngaphandle kwembono yokulingana, kukwakho, kwigama elithi "umtshato", ukukhangela ukwamkelwa ".

Kwisicatshulwa, uPapa Francis uphendula ngokufutshane: "Kodwa ayingomtshato, lumanyano lwaseburhulumenteni".

Ngokusekwe kwisalathiso, olunye uphononongo, kubandakanya nolupapashwe kwiphephancwadi laseMelika, lathi kule ncwadi uPapa "uyayiphinda into yakhe yokutshata umtshato wesini esinye kodwa wamkela umanyano lwabesini esinye."

Iintatheli ezivela e-Cna nakwezinye iindaba ziye zacela i-ofisi yeendaba e-Vatican ukuba icaciselwe ngomthombo wodliwanondlebe kapopu, kodwa abakayifumani impendulo